When True Crime Storytelling Becomes Harm

 

True crime sits at a complicated intersection: it is part journalism, part entertainment, part advocacy, and sometimes part amateur investigation. That combination can be powerful. It can also be dangerous when handled without discipline.

Without standards, several patterns emerge:

  • Reputational harm to individuals who are discussed without sufficient evidence or context
  • Distortion of facts, where speculation is presented as narrative truth
  • Retraumatization of victims and families, whose lives are revisited for content without consent or care
  • Public misinterpretation of unresolved cases, leading to confusion, harassment, or interference

The issue is not that true crime exists. The issue is how it is being produced.

There is a fundamental difference between storytelling that informs and storytelling that exploits. And right now, the line between those two is often blurred—or ignored entirely.

Empathy is often cited as the solution. Creators talk about “holding space” for victims, about telling stories with care, about honoring those affected. But empathy cannot be situational. It cannot be something that is performed when it aligns with a narrative and abandoned when it complicates one. It is not enough to say “engage with empathy” when it meets your agenda. It has to be a way of life—embedded in every decision, every edit, every claim that is made public.

Because when empathy is selective, it stops being ethics. It becomes branding.



Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A generic sketch, a distinctive car, and the details that still deserve a second look in the Melissa Witt case

Image
 I came across this article again — “Police ask for help finding Witt witness” — and I want to zero in on the specific details it included about the man and the vehicle, because those are the pieces that still have the potential to matter. According to the article, the man investigators were trying to identify was described as being between 20 and 30 years old, approximately 5 feet 11 inches tall, and weighing around 180 pounds. He had curly strawberry blond hair and possibly a beard. He was reportedly seen near the location where Melissa Witt’s body was later found, and what stood out to the witness was that he appeared out of place — notably, he did not have any hunting equipment with him. At one point, he was also seen changing clothes in that area. The vehicle associated with him was described in much more specific detail. It was a dark gray or black newer model car. It had what appeared to be a racing stripe or decal on the passenger side rear quarter panel, possibly in pur...
Read more

When True Crime Loses Its Compass

Image
Why I Wrote Two SSRN Papers on Ethics, Accountability, and the Real Cost of Storytelling I’ve spent years working in the true crime space—as a writer, advocate, and someone who has walked alongside victims’ families and unresolved cases that don’t neatly fit into headlines or narratives. Over time, I began to see something that concerned me deeply: the gap between storytelling and responsibility. True crime has grown into one of the most powerful forms of modern media, yet the ethical guardrails that exist in traditional journalism are often missing. That realization led me to step back and do something different. Instead of just participating in the space, I wanted to study it, define it, and create a framework that could help protect both victims and the integrity of the work itself. I recently published two SSRN papers that reflect that effort—both grounded in ethics, accountability, and the real-world consequences of how stories are told. The first paper, Ethics in True Crime Podca...
Read more

Walking in the Light Through the Dark: Can a Christian Truly Engage in True Crime Without Losing Their Way?

Image
It is a question I have been asked more than once, sometimes gently and sometimes with an edge of concern: how can someone who professes faith—who believes in grace, redemption, and the sacred value of human life—also immerse themselves in stories of violence, loss, and the worst things people do to one another? It is not an unreasonable question. At first glance, Christianity and true crime can seem like opposing forces, one rooted in hope and the other steeped in darkness. But the truth is more complex, and far more honest. The tension people feel comes from what true crime has become in many spaces. It is often packaged as entertainment, consumed casually, and discussed in ways that can strip victims of their dignity and reduce human suffering to content. That version of true crime should make anyone uncomfortable, especially someone guided by faith. There is nothing Christ-like about exploiting pain, speculating recklessly about real lives, or turning tragedy into spectacle. If t...
Read more